The prevention of cartilage damage that we are talking about in the field of knee surgery is an extremely current problem because the treatment of degenerative joint processes is assuming proportions that were unthinkable until a few decades ago. The lengthening of the average life span, the spread of sport and unfortunately the indiscriminate aggression that has been perpetrated in recent years against the meniscal structures make us today witness an increase in knee chondropathies even in relatively young subjects.
With the advent of arthroscopy, our diagnostic and therapeutic capabilities have improved and now we try to save the meniscal structures whenever possible.
The menisci in fact play an essential role in the joint mechanics of the knee: they act as shock absorbers reducing the load to which the joint surfaces are subjected by absorbing approximately 50% of the load in extension and 80% when the knee is at 90° of flexion. Furthermore, they reduce friction and increase the stability of the knee both by improving joint congruity and by acting as proprioceptive structures.
Their removal leads to progressive degenerative alterations; a total meniscectomy in fact reduces the contact surface by approximately 50% and amplifies the overall deformation of the articular cartilage on the subchondral bone in the upright position.
Blood supply to the menisci is limited to the most peripheral 25–30% of the meniscus itself and originates from the surrounding soft tissues: the synovial membrane and the capsule.
Some studies have described the healing phenomena whereby the lesions that are connected to the vascular portion can heal through the formation of a scar of fibrocartilaginous tissue whose resistance has not yet been precisely determined. The current trend is therefore to save the menisci by suturing them or in any case by removing as little tissue as possible where there are no indications for a suture and leaving a regular residual portion.
Knee articular cartilage lesions are frequently found in athletes and are often associated with meniscal damage. The role of meniscal lesions in the pathogenesis of femoral-tibial cartilage lesions remains a subject of much debate.
Although it is commonly accepted that meniscal lesions can lead to femoro-tibial cartilage degeneration, many studies reach contradictory results regarding the effects of a partial meniscectomy in a knee with pre-existing chondral damage and regarding the causal link between the two lesions.
A torn meniscus does not always lead to cartilage damage, other mechanisms are in fact at the basis of chondropathy that often precedes meniscal damage. A positive correlation has however been found between the time elapsed from the moment of the injury to surgical treatment and the severity of the lesions found.
Chondral lesions of the medial compartment are much more frequent than those of the lateral compartment regardless of the presence or absence of a meniscal lesion, however medial lesions are more frequently associated with chondral damage than lateral ones; the internal compartment is normally subjected to higher loads and in the case of a meniscal lesion is more affected by the aberrant movement centers that are created; in particular, an unstable meniscal lesion determines abnormal movements of the joint that produce increased shear and compression forces that are discharged directly on the articular cartilage creating damage in one or more compartments. Stable meniscal lesions are less likely to produce cartilage damage while bucket handle lesions, flaps and inferior lesions with a horizontal cleavage plane are more frequently associated with cartilage degeneration.
Unfortunately, the symptoms reported by the patient are not a sure predictor of the state of the articular cartilage, and often the cartilage degeneration found during the arthroscopic examination is of a higher degree than could have been expected before the operation.
Treatments
First of all, it is the doctor’s task to educate the patient before the athlete, by implementing a change in activity and behavioral norms, the subject must be directed towards a program of physical and rehabilitative therapies with mobilization and muscle strengthening, such simple treatments associated with the reduction of body weight can effectively contribute to the reduction of symptoms and increase the residual “joint life”.
Postural gymnastics, training with limited unloading or load, the use of plantar insoles and/or knee pads can be useful to modify the joint stress axis by decreasing the wear of the cartilage.
Pharmacological therapy with anti-inflammatory drugs should not be used with the casualness with which it is often employed, nevertheless it plays a fundamental role in the control of pain in the hyperacute phases: in fact, anti-inflammatory drugs decrease the synthesis of prostaglandins and consequently reduce pain, they should be taken intermittently since their use for prolonged periods can cause significant side effects.
Cortisone, especially if injected intra-articularly, is a dangerous drug and should be used with caution.
Alternative medicines such as taking products based on shark cartilage, or chondroitin sulphate and glucosamine can also be used for long periods as they are free from significant side effects, but their usefulness is still a matter of debate.
Electrical stimulation (Tens) often offers a temporary benefit in the absence of side effects; acupuncture is also a treatment used in the treatment of pain and should be investigated more thoroughly to demonstrate the mechanism of action and the correct use.
Physical therapies, hot/cold, ultrasound, magneto/radar, shock waves, can be beneficial and have no significant contraindications.
Intra-articular infiltrations with hyaluronic acid have been shown to be extremely useful both for reducing pain and joint swelling and for promoting healing processes in modest-grade lesions; cartilage is in fact made up of proteoglycans that are damaged early by the arthritic process; hyaluronic acid is a component of synovial fluid and plays a fundamental role in joint lubrication, and it has been shown that its level decreases in the arthritic process.
A new strategy for the treatment of chondropathies and prevention of arthrosis is the administration of hyaluronic acid with high viscosity injected intra-articularly. Recent studies have shown that these beneficial effects tend to last for several months.
Another strategy recently used to limit joint overload is the use of special knee braces that, worn during sports, reduce the joint load in the part subject to wear (unloading braces). New research has demonstrated the ability of these braces to normalize the joint load in subjects with anomalies of the joint axis (varus/valgus knee).
Movement, physical exercise and body weight control are finally the simplest and most accessible system for everyone to limit the risk of osteoarthritis, it is essential to exercise the joint at least once a day, favoring activities with limited load (bicycle, swimming, exercises in the gym). A few minutes are enough to maintain good muscle tone, joint mobility and flexibility; the exercise must not cause pain or joint swelling and expert guidance is necessary to avoid incorrect activities or overloads. The position in which you sleep (avoid staying curled up for many hours) and 5 minutes of stretching upon waking will help you better face the new day.


