Knees do not wear evenly. In fact, they do not wear out at all unless there is an underlying injury. This could be a meniscus or ligament tear, or the result of a disease such as osteoarthritis. Knee cartilage is extremely durable and, if not damaged, lasts a lifetime.
However, once the injury has occurred, the degree of wear and tear depends on the type and location of the injury. Many patients with arthritic knees are told that they need a complete knee replacement, when in fact just resurfacing the worn part would do just fine.
In fact, 80 percent of people who are told they need a total knee replacement actually do not need one at all. There are two other options. The first is a biological prosthesis, in which we replace the meniscus, reconstruct the ligaments, or repair the articular cartilage using a grafting technique. This is our specialized biological surgical reconstruction program, called BioKnee. However, if there is bone-on-bone on the X-ray, there is not enough room to replace the missing tissues with natural ones. In this context, an artificial partial knee replacement, also called a unicondylar replacement, is often the best option.
These partial replacements (actually remakes of the worn area) were not commonly performed in the past because it was difficult to accurately match the resurfaced parts with the undamaged knee. Computer models and robotic arms have changed all that.
Today, with robotic assistance, we can treat each part of the knee independently or in combination on an outpatient basis. For example, you can treat just the patella and trochlea (the upper part of the femur where the patella rubs) or just the medial or lateral (inner or outer) part of the knee. It is also possible to perform a combination.
The results of the partial knee replacement have become so good that my patients often ask me, “Can I run, can I play sports, can I return to all my activities? My answer is, “Yes, but…”. Here’s why:
When many patients come in for knee pain, they have been limping for years. Their muscles are weak and their range of motion is limited as their hip and back mechanics have compensated for the arthritic knee. In order to return to sports without damaging the knee joint, each of these limitations must be addressed first with extensive physical therapy and fitness training.
Let’s say you go back to running. If you walk a mile or run a mile, what exerts more force on the knee? It turns out that the total force may be the same, since you take fewer steps when you run. However, peak forces are higher with running. Therefore, if you are going to run on an injured, arthritic or repaired knee, it makes sense to refine your running style. Shorter strides, midfoot landings, and running on soft surfaces such as grass or sand combined with smooth styles (such as Chi running) can lower peak forces.
With modern outpatient robotic techniques, partial knee replacements and sports are now free. But as with all activities, the quality of movement affects the outcome.


